Working With Old Newspaper Obituaries: What You Actually Need to Know
Van Wert, Ohio had its share of local newspapers over the years. The Van Wert Independent ran for decades, and the obituaries it published are scattered across microfilm, digitized snippets, and a few printed scrapbooks that ended up in basement archives. If you are trying to piece together family history from them, you quickly learn that the process is not clean. The first thing you need to understand is that not every death got an obituary in that paper. The Independent was a small-town weekly for most of its run, and space was limited. Affluent families, prominent local figures, and people with friends on the police force or city council tended to get the full treatment. Your great-grandmother might have been buried with a paragraph while her husband, who ran a hardware store, got a two-line notice if at all. This is normal. It does not mean anything is missing from your research. It just means the coverage was uneven, as it was everywhere. I spent about six months last year pulling obituaries from the Van Wert area for a client whose family trace crossed three generations. I started with the obvious route, the Library of Congress Chronicling America site. A handful of issues from the early 1900s are scanned there, but the coverage stops around 1922 and picks up spotty again later. What you find online is a sample, not the archive.
The real collection lives at the Van Wert County Public Library on North Sandusky Street. They have the microfilm reels for the Independent dating from the late 1800s through the 1970s or so. The library staff will let you view the microfilm on site. There is no charge. You bring your own camera or phone if you want a digital copy, though the lighting on the reader is harsh and reading glasses help if you are over forty. I usually photograph pages directly from the screen rather than trying to scan them by hand. It takes longer but gives you something you can search later with OCR software. One edge case that tripped me up involved a death in 1934. The obituary was listed under the surname "Hartman" but the deceased had legally changed her name a decade earlier after a second marriage. The index at the library filed it under her new name, but the actual article used her maiden name because the family submitted it that way. I missed her entirely on my first pass. The workaround is to cross-reference the Van Wert County death records, which are held by the county auditor's office. Those records list the name as it appeared on the death certificate, which usually matches what the family actually used, not necessarily what was in the published notice. Comparing the two sources catches about a third of these mismatches. Digitization projects exist but they are incomplete. FamilySearch has some Van Wert county records, and Ancestry has a few obituary collections from Ohio, but neither covers the full run of the Independent. You will waste time searching those sites before realizing you need to go to the physical archive or request a copy through the library. I have found that ordering a reproduction copy through the library costs about five dollars per page and arrives in two weeks. For a small number of entries it is faster than scheduling a trip. For heavier research, the trip pays for itself.
Another thing people overlook is the society pages. Obituaries were sometimes grouped with church notices, social club announcements, and birthday mentions. A full obituary might run on page four next to a list of wedding guests. If you are only scanning the death notices section, you will miss context that could explain why certain families received more coverage than others. The Independent followed the pattern of most small papers: the editorial page carried local politics, the society page carried the personal news, and the back pages carried the ads. The obituaries sat wherever the editor decided they fit on that week's layout. Pitfalls to avoid: assume the date on the obituary is the date of death. It is usually the date the paper was published, which for a weekly like the Independent could be three to five days after the person died. If you need an exact death date for genealogical purposes, check the death certificate or the funeral home record. Also, do not trust the indexing alone. Handwritten indexes from the 1950s and earlier contain transcription errors. I found a case where "Van Wert" was misread as "Wana Valley" in one index card, and the obituary was filed under a completely wrong location heading. Always verify against the original microfilm. If you are looking for a download link, there is not a single comprehensive digital archive you can pull from. The best available resources are the microfilm at the Van Wert County Public Library, the scanned fragments on Chronicling America, and the Ohio Genealogical Society's database which has some transcribed entries. None of these replace the physical archive. The work of going through it slowly, checking each name against death records and census data, is what actually produces results. That part cannot be automated away.
Get the Full Details
