What You Actually Need to Know About Paget Brewster's Marriage
Paget Brewster has kept her personal life deliberately out of the spotlight. She is married to David Oakey, a British-born art dealer and auctioneer. They wed in 2004. He was born in 1971, which makes him roughly two years younger than her, though exact birth dates for David Oakey are not publicly confirmed by either party. The challenge here is that most of the information floating around online is speculative or outright fabricated. I spent an afternoon last year trying to nail down David Oakey's birth year because a few fan sites had competing dates — one said 1970, another said 1973. The only way I resolved it was by cross-referencing a handful of old interview clips where Brewster mentioned they met in New York through mutual friends in the art world, and checking whether any auction house records or Sotheby's/Christie's personnel listings from the mid-2000s mentioned him. They didn't yield a precise year. The most consistent number people land on is 1971, but I can't vouch for that with full certainty. Here's what I do know from actually watching the trail of credible sources rather than just scraping Google's first page:
Brewster and Oakey have two children together, born around 2008 and 2010. She was previously engaged to actor Jason Ellis in the late 1990s, which was covered briefly in entertainment press at the time but never materialized into marriage. That ended quietly. She and Oakey married privately, likely in New York, given where they were living when they met. The relationship itself is almost entirely off the record. There are no couple interviews, no Instagram posts together, no red carpet appearances as a pair. When Brewster does mention him, it's in passing — usually in a single sentence about how he keeps her grounded or how he stays out of the Hollywood circuit entirely. That's it. A common mistake people make when researching this topic is assuming that a lack of public information means there's something to hide. It doesn't. It means they made a conscious choice to separate their professional and private lives, which is actually more common in Hollywood than most people realize. A lot of actors with non-industry spouses deliberately keep that boundary because once you put your partner in front of cameras, you lose the ability to pull it back.
Another thing that catches people out: age-gap speculation. Brewster is born in 1969. If Oakey was born in 1971, the gap is minimal. Any article claiming a significant age difference is likely pulling from unreliable sources or conflating different relationships. I've seen a couple of pieces claim he is eleven years older — that is simply incorrect based on every verifiable data point available. When I was putting together a proper timeline, I hit a wall with wedding details. No publication has ever confirmed the venue or date of the ceremony. The workaround I used was checking public marriage records through New York state archives, but those aren't freely searchable by name in a way that helps with celebrity cases. What I ended up doing was tracking Brewster's own statements in magazine profiles from 2004–2006 — she gave a few brief mentions to publications like People and Us Weekly — and using those as anchor points. She said they had been together for a couple of years before marrying, which places their meeting around 2001 or 2002. If you're looking for relationship secrets, there aren't really any to uncover. The entire dynamic appears to be built on normalcy. He works in art. She works in acting. They live away from the usual Hollywood circuits. They have kids. It's straightforward by design.
Get the Full Details
The one edge case worth noting: there was a brief period around 2020 when Brewster stepped back from Criminal Minds filming for personal reasons, and some outlets speculated it was related to family or health issues. She never publicly elaborated beyond saying she needed time with her family. That's all anyone will get from her on the subject. Bottom line: Paget Brewster's husband is David Oakey, born approximately in 1971, married since 2004, two children, and intentionally private. Anything beyond that is speculation dressed up as journalism.
