What You Need to Know About Alysha Clark's Relationship History
Alysha Clark, the former WWE Diva turned YouTube personality and author, has been relatively open about her personal life over the years. If you're trying to piece together who she's been involved with, the timeline is straightforward but scattered across social media posts, podcast appearances, and occasional interviews. The most significant relationship in her public life is with Johnny Gargano. They met around 2013 when both were working in WWE's developmental system. Clark was part of the diva roster while Gargano was training as a wrestler. Their relationship wasn't immediately public, which is fairly standard for wrestlers at that level. Management tends to discourage overt publicity around personal relationships during the early career phase because it can create complications with storylines and networking. They got married in December 2016. The wedding was kept relatively private, with only close friends and family in attendance. A few photos leaked afterward, but neither of them gave a major interview about it at the time. Clark mentioned it briefly on her podcast and social media in the following months. They have two children together, a daughter named Aria and a son named Cruz. Keeping family matters out of the spotlight seems to be a priority for them.
Before Gargano, Clark was involved with a man named Tim Donst, a professional wrestler known for his work in independent circuits. That relationship ended years before she joined WWE. She didn't discuss it publicly for a long time. When she did mention it on her podcast around 2019 or 2020, she kept it short and moved on. Nothing dramatic or exposé-style. There's been some speculation about her current status after her split from Gargano. They announced their separation in early 2023. Clark posted about it on her social channels with a message that was fairly matter-of-fact. She didn't go into detailed reasons. Gargano also released a statement that was similar in tone—neutral, respectful, and brief. Since then, neither has confirmed a new relationship publicly. There have been rumors, mostly on fan forums and TikTok, but nothing verified. Speculation about who she might be dating now is almost entirely based on and paparazzi-adjacent social media posts, which are unreliable by nature. If you're researching this for content creation, here's a practical tip that might save you hours: use Wayback Machine snapshots alongside Instagram archives rather than relying on current posts. People delete or make accounts private after splits, and those posts disappear from search results quickly. I spent about three hours tracking down a deleted podcast clip where Clark mentioned her relationship timeline indirectly. The audio was eventually found archived on a fan Discord server that mirrored episodes before they got taken down. If you're looking for something specific, check archived podcast directories like Podbay or even Reddit threads from the original air dates. Screenshots from those threads tend to hold up better than links.
One thing beginners often miss when researching celebrity relationships is that WWE-era publicists deliberately controlled what was shared. Any photos or posts from the 2013 to 2016 period went through approval. That means even casual Instagram posts from back then may have been filtered for what the company considered acceptable publicity. Don't treat every old post as completely unfiltered truth. Cross-reference with podcast appearances where she spoke off the record, which tend to be more candid since they weren't subject to the same corporate review process. The main limitation here is that reliable information is sparse past 2023. After the separation, both Clark and Gargano have kept their personal lives out of the media. Clark has focused on her podcast, her book, and her YouTube channel content. She occasionally references her family life in general terms but avoids naming current partners or details. This is by design, not omission. There are no credible sources confirming a new boyfriend as of now. Any article claiming otherwise is likely based on rumor or fabricated content. I'd recommend treating those with skepticism unless they cite a direct statement from Clark herself or a verified mutual acquaintance. For people building a timeline, the most reliable sources are her own podcast appearances, her published book "Beautiful Mess," and verified social media accounts. Anything from gossip sites or fan theory channels should be cross-checked before being treated as fact. The information density on this topic is low compared to other celebrity relationship topics simply because Clark and Gargano have chosen privacy over publicity regarding their personal lives post-split.
Get the Full Details
