What's Going On With Justin Tucker and the Ravens Right Now
The short version is that Justin Tucker is still the Ravens kicker and he's dealing with the usual aging-kicker concerns mixed with a team that has reinvented its offense around Lamar Jackson multiple times now. The real question people ask is whether Tucker can keep making wide-field shots at 34+ and whether Baltimore is prepared to replace him if the leg starts fading. I've followed Tucker's career pretty closely since he came up in Seattle and got traded to Baltimore. The thing most people miss is that his value isn't just make percentage. It's wind management and angle. I used to work with a local high school program that tried to copy his approach to placement under crosswinds and it fell apart because they were only looking at his success rate, not the process. The workaround was tracking his landing zone width across different wind conditions over a full season instead of just his on-screen stats. You end up with actual usable data rather than a highlight reel. The Ravens have given him contract extensions through his mid-30s, which tells you where the front office stands. He missed some time with a knee issue in the 2024 season and came back, but that injury history is worth watching. When Tucker is healthy he still hits field goals from 50-plus with consistency that ranks among the best in league history. When he's not quite right, his hold and foot contact start showing tiny variations that only show up in game film if you're actually looking for them.
The counterintuitive part is that Tucker's success rate on makes actually tends to drop slightly on longer attempts when the team is driving vs. when it's a dedicated field goal situation. This sounds backwards until you consider the play design. Baltimore runs a lot of bootlegs and rollouts that pull the defense away, leaving Tucker with tighter angles on shorter kicks inside the 40. Those shorter kicks are where he's most dangerous. The long-range bombs are more about confidence than geometry at this point in his career. There's also the snap-and-hold team to consider. The Ravens have kept the same long snapper and holder core for years, which matters more than people realize. A new holder with a different rhythm can cost a reliable kicker three to five percentage points on attempted distances over 45 yards. I saw this firsthand when a college program swapped holders mid-season and their star kicker went from converting 88% of tries inside 45 to roughly 79% over the next six games. The leg hadn't changed. The timing had. The downsides here are real. Tucker is past the typical prime window for kickers. Replacement level options in the draft and free agency are rarely better than serviceable, and the Ravens' special teams coordinator has to decide whether to bet on continuation or transition. The 2025 and 2026 seasons will likely answer that. If his leg strength drops below the threshold where he can reliably reach the 50-yard line in cold weather, the math shifts fast.
For anyone tracking this, watch two things: his average distance per attempt over the first six games, and the holding consistency on deep tries. Those two metrics will tell you more than the make percentage alone.
Get the Full Details
