Where to actually get good pizza in Phoenix
I live here, I eat pizza a lot, and most of what people call "top spots" online is either sponsored garbage or copy-pasted blog content. Let me save you some time and drive. Slice of Heaven is one of the places that actually deserves mention. It’s not perfect, but it’s consistently decent, which in Phoenix is more than you can say for half the Neapolitan pretend-restaurants popping up everywhere. Their dough has a proper char on the cornicione without being ashtray-bitter, and the sauce hits at the right acidity level. Not too sweet, not tasting like ketchup with herbs shaken onto it. I’ve eaten there enough times to notice their consistency is actually maintained. A lot of places do great for three months and then let things slide once the initial buzz dies down. Slice of Heaven hasn’t done that. Margherita is straightforward and correct. The pepperoni cups and crisps properly. If you’re driving from Scottsdale or Tempe, it’s worth the trip, though parking is mediocre during Friday and Saturday evenings.
The real issue I run into with slice shops in this city is the oven situation. Phoenix gets to 110 degrees in the summer, and a lot of these places are running deck ovens in spaces that weren’t designed for them. The ambient heat messes with your bake times. I learned this the hard way at a place in Mesa last July — ordered a white pie, came out in six minutes instead of eight, crust was pale and doughy in the center. I asked about it. Turns out the oven calibration had drifted from the heat soak. They adjusted it, and the next visit was fine. Just something to keep in mind when you’re going during peak summer months. Beyond Slice of Heaven, here’s what’s actually worth eating at: Frank’s Pizza in central Phoenix. This is old-school Detroit style. Rectangular pans, cheese to the edges, lacy crust. They’ve been doing it since the 1980s without changing much, which is rare. The issue is the wait. If you go on a Thursday night past 7 PM, you’re looking at 45 minutes for a pie. Go at 5:30 and you’re in and out. Also, they don’t take online orders. Cash and card at the counter, period.
Orso in downtown Phoenix. Wood-fired, Neapolitan-leaning. The dough is fermented longer than a lot of places I’ve eaten at — probably 72 hours based on the texture. That extra fermentation time is what gives it that tang without needing heavy hand-tossing of oregano on top. Their sourdough pie is the one most people skip but should try. It’s different, not better for everyone, but it’s well-executed. Ralph’s Pizza. Again, old school. No fancy stuff. Just pan pizza done right. The garlic is strong and the sauce has that particular sweetness that comes from slow-cooked tomato paste rather than added sugar. It’s exactly what you want at 1 AM after going out. One thing people miss when searching for top spots: the best pizza in Phoenix isn’t always the most photographed. A lot of the Instagram-friendly places are baking at higher temperatures for faster turnover, which means less development in the crust. You’re paying for the aesthetic, not the product. Frank’s and Ralph’s look like they haven’t been updated since 1992. The food is why people keep coming back.
Get the Full Details
If you’re driving into Phoenix from the valley suburbs and specifically want Slice of Heaven, take 7th Street off I-17. It’s an unmarked sign, easy to miss. Go early. The lunch crowd clears out by 2 PM and that’s when the oven temps stabilize after the morning rush. Pizza baked at 3 PM is noticeably better than the 12 PM batch at this location. I don’t know if it’s the oven recovery or just that the dough has had more time on the proof, but I’ve compared side-by-side. That’s basically it. Eat at the places that have been around a while. Skip the ones that launched with a $12 margherita and a chalkboard menu written in Sharpie.
