So You Want To Read "The Slytherin Alumnus Uncovering The Mysteries Of Horace Slughorn's Wand"
This is a Harry Potter fan fiction piece that's been circulating on the usual writing platforms. It's not official canon, obviously. Slughorn wasn't exactly a character Rowling spent a ton of time developing outside of a few key moments, so fans naturally filled in gaps. The story reimagines him as a Slytherin alumnus (canonical, since he was sorted into Slytherin) and has him investigating his own wand's history. It's a decent character study mixed with lore speculation. If you're looking for where to read it, it's primarily hosted on Archive of Our Own (AO3) and some smaller HP fan forums. Search the exact title on AO3. It's tagged as an independent fic, so you won't find it on any official Rowling property or Pottermore/Wizarding World site. The author has posted it under a pseudonym with no affiliation to the franchise. If you hit a paywall somewhere, it's likely a repost mirror — go to the original source instead. What the story actually does is interesting from a lore perspective. Slughorn's wand isn't mentioned in the books, which is rare for a named Hogwarts professor. Rowling named wands for Harry, Hermione, Voldemort, Dumbledore, and Snape, but left Slughorn's blank. This fic does the speculative work of filling that gap. The premise involves a Slytherin student — possibly contemporary with or after Slughorn's time — tracing the lineage of what might have been Slughorn's wand. It touches on the concept of wand loyalty, which is canon-adjacent but never deeply explored for anyone outside the main trio.
Here's the practical problem I ran into: I tried to track down the author's update schedule or a complete list of chapters, and the AO3 page had no clear summary. Some fic pages like this one just dump text without chapter listings if the author uploaded it in a weird format. I ended up having to check the kudos and comments to piece together the actual order, because the default sort on the site wasn't matching the narrative chronology. The workaround was straightforward — I filtered by "most kudos" and read the comment timestamps to reconstruct the real sequence. Most people don't bother with that and just read sequentially, which works fine if you don't mind the occasional timeline jump. The writing quality is above average for HP fan fiction. The author clearly understands wandlore conventions — holly, phoenix feather, eleven inches — and plays with them rather than just name-dropping. Where it gets genuinely good is the treatment of Slughorn as a morally ambiguous figure. Canon Slughorn is already complicated: he hoarded powerful students for his collection, he gave Tom Riddle crucial information about Horcruxes, and then he switched sides essentially because the war was going badly. The fic leans into that self-preservation instinct and makes it a central theme rather than a joke. One thing most readers miss: the story references the wandmaker Gregorovitch without making a huge deal out of it. That's a smart touch. Gregorovitch was a Bulgarian wandmaker whose work eventually ended up in the hands of various dark witches and wizards. By tying Slughorn's wand to that broader network, the author creates a plausible connection between the magical world's underworld and the seemingly ordinary faculty at Hogwarts. It's easy to skim past, but it matters for understanding why the wand's history is tied to Slytherin specifically.
There are also canonical details about what we know of Slughorn's personality that the story uses effectively. He collects things — notable people, memories, stories. A wand that has a history worth uncovering fits that pattern perfectly. The fic treats this almost like a detective story, which is unusual for the typical Slash-era HP fic ecosystem. Most writers in this space go for romance or AU modern settings. This one stays in the wizarding world and asks a specific, narrow question: what does a man like Slughorn carry in his pocket? A common pitfall I see: readers often assume the wand itself is the mystery, when really the story is about Slughorn's complicity. The wand is just the object that anchors the investigation. If you go in expecting a straightforward magical artifact history, you'll come away frustrated. The wand's origin matters less than why Slughorn kept it and what it represents about his choices. The fic runs about 40,000 to 50,000 words depending on which version you read. The AO3 upload is the most complete. Some earlier versions posted on smaller forums were truncated, probably because the author revised sections and lost track of which was final. If you find a shorter version, it's likely outdated. Check the revision history on AO3 if you want to confirm — some chapters were significantly reworked between uploads.
Get the Full Details
Is it perfect? No. The pacing drags in the middle section where the investigation stalls for a few chapters. Some dialogue feels too on-the-nose, particularly when characters explain wandlore they've clearly just learned. The author is doing exposition and sometimes forgets that people in the Wizarding World take these things for granted. That said, the ending resolves the central thread cleanly without forcing a false sense of closure that isn't earned. If you're coming from the books and want something that respects canon while expanding on it, this is a solid choice. If you're looking for action or drama, it's not that kind of story. It's a character study wrapped in a mystery, which is a narrower genre than most HP fan fiction targets. But it does the work it sets out to do without overreaching or disrespecting the source material. I'd recommend reading it in one or two sittings rather than spread out over weeks. The mystery structure means earlier clues matter, and the episodic nature of some upload formats can make you forget small details between chapters. Save it, start fresh, and you'll get more out of it than someone who reads a chapter a day while checking for plot holes.
