So You Want to Talk About the 8 Immortals Kung Fu Box Set
I picked up the 8 Immortals box set about three years ago after seeing it pop up on every martial arts forum. Everyone had an opinion on it. Some people swear by it as the definitive collection of classic northern-style kung fu cinema. Others say the transfer quality is sloppy. I'm somewhere in the middle, and I've spent enough time with these discs to give you a straight answer on whether it's worth your money. Let me just get to the point. The box set contains eight films, each representing a different "immortal" archetype from Chinese martial arts folklore. The lineup typically includes titles like Legend of the 8 Immortals, The Eight Immortals Cross the Sea, and several other Shaw Brothers and independent Hong Kong productions from the late 1970s to mid-1980s. What makes it interesting is not the individual quality of every film, but the fact that they're to find together on DVD in a single package. Here's the thing most reviewers skip over. The actual martial arts choreography in these films is solid, but not groundbreaking. The obsession comes from the rarity factor. A lot of these titles were never properly released on home video before. They existed on VHS bootlegs or laserdisc imports. Getting them on region-free DVDs with English subtitles was a big deal for collectors.
I had a specific problem when I first watched these. The second disc, which contains the longest film in the set, had a audible hum throughout the entire runtime. It wasn't a skip or a glitch. It was just a consistent audio issue baked into the encode. I spent about twenty minutes trying different players and cables before I figured out it wasn't my setup. I eventually found a forum thread where three other people confirmed the same issue on their copies. The workaround was to use the audio track from a different region's release of the same film, which I ripped from a separate purchase. The visual quality on that track was worse, but the hum was gone. Nobody mentions this in the reviews.
What's Actually in the Box
The eight films run anywhere from 75 minutes to just over 2 hours each. The total runtime is roughly 13 to 14 hours across the set. Most of the action sequences are well-shot for their era. The fight choreography leans heavily on northern style movements — crane, tiger, snake, and leopard forms are all represented at some point. If you're studying traditional martial arts forms for performance or film reference, these are useful. Not essential, but useful. The subtitle quality is mixed. Some discs have accurate translations. Others have subtitles that clearly came from a machine translation that was never proofread. I once saw a fight scene description translated as something that made no grammatical sense in English. It took me a few viewings to figure out what was actually being said in the original Cantonese. When the subs are bad, pay attention to the dialogue audio. The actors usually make their intentions clear through delivery even when the subtitles miss the mark.
Get the Full Details
The Encoding and Video Quality
This is where the set gets complicated. The source materials come from different eras and different original masters. The Shaw Brothers films generally look better than the independent productions. That's just the nature of the source. The Shaw material was remastered from original camera negatives when possible. The independent films were often sourced from second-generation video tapes that had been circulating for decades. Compression artifacts show up in darker scenes, especially during fight choreography where fast movement meets low bitrate encoding. Edge detail is soft on several of the discs. If you watch on a large television, it's noticeable. On a smaller screen or laptop, it's acceptable. I'd estimate the video quality is roughly equivalent to a good DVB broadcast from the early 2000s. Don't expect Blu-ray detail. This is standard definition content that hasn't been upgraded. One counter-intuitive point that nobody talks about. The softer image quality actually works in favor of the martial arts choreography in some cases. The compression removes some of the grain and texture that can distract from the movement. When you're watching to study the forms and footwork, the slightly smoothed image can make it easier to follow what the performers are doing. It's not a reason to buy the set, but it's a practical observation from someone who uses these films for training reference.
Audio and Sound Design
The audio tracks are mostly Cantonese or Mandarin with optional English subtitles. The dubbing quality varies by film. Some have been properly redubbed for international release. Others are just the original language track with subtitles, which means you hear ambient noise, crew chatter, and production sounds that weren't cleaned up. The music is generally functional score work — serviceable but forgettable. If you're watching for the combat, you won't notice. If you're watching for the soundtrack, look elsewhere. I ran into an edge case with one of the discs where the audio and video were slightly out of sync. About half a second off, which becomes noticeable during rapid fight sequences. I adjusted the delay setting on my player to compensate. Most DVD players allow you to shift audio by a few hundred milliseconds. If you experience this, check the lip sync settings before assuming the disc is defective.
Who Should Buy This
If you're a dedicated student of Hong Kong martial arts cinema from the late 1970s and early 1980s, this set fills a gap in your collection. The films are not all classics. Some are B-movie level productions with limited budgets and shorter running times. But together they give you a reasonably complete picture of what was being made outside the major studios. If you're new to the genre, I'd recommend starting with a single well-regarded film first. The set assumes you already know what you're getting into. The packaging doesn't describe the individual films in enough detail for a beginner to make an informed choice about each one. Read the plot summaries elsewhere before you commit to the full box. The main downside is the price-to-quality ratio. You're paying for rarity, not for a premium remaster. If the same films become available on a proper high-definition release, this set will lose most of its appeal. Until then, it's the best option most collectors have. Just go in with realistic expectations about what you're buying.
