Why I Keep Going Back to Paint Tool Sai 2
I've used Photoshop for over a decade. I've used Clip Studio Paint, Krita, Procreate. Paint Tool Sai 2 still lives on my desktop and I open it more often than most of the others. Not because it's nostalgic. Because it does one thing better than anything else I've found.
Paint Tool Sai 2 The Underrated Digital Art Powerhouse Redefining Creative Workflows
Most people dismiss Sai because the interface looks like it stopped evolving around 2014. The truth is the opposite. The software got it right early and barely needed changes. What you see is basically what you get. No menus buried under sub-menus. No panels that rearrange themselves after an update and make you spend forty-five minutes finding your brushes again. The brush engine is the reason people stay. It has what the company calls the Stabilizer feature, which smooths your strokes in a way that actually feels different from the stabilizers in other programs. It doesn't just lag behind your cursor. It calculates a smoother path through your points without adding the sticky, wax-crayon drag that happens in Clip Studio's correction settings or the overly stiff response you get from Photoshop's Streamline. Here is how the workflow actually looks in practice. I open Sai, set the canvas to 4000 by 5600 pixels at 300 DPI for print work, pick the G-Pen, crank the stabilizer to about 35, and start blocking in lineart. That stabilizer setting is the number one thing I tell anyone who tries Sai for the first time. The default is too low for most people. You get jittery lines and you think the program is bad. It isn't. The pen pressure curve is also something you need to adjust immediately. Out of the box, the default pressure response is too soft. Most of my lineart work sits between seventy and eighty percent pressure sensitivity with a moderately steep curve. Without that change, your lightest strokes disappear entirely and your heaviest ones look muddy. The layer system is minimal but it works. You have layer opacity, blend modes like multiply and add, and clipping masks. That is enough for most illustration work. I usually layer my lineart on one layer, flat colors underneath on another, and shading on a third set to multiply. Shadows in Sai look cleaner than they do in Photoshop because the Add blend mode doesn't push colors into full white the way it does in programs with wider color Gamuts. You can shade a character and it stays within the range of the original palette instead of blowing out to neon pink on the highlights.
There is one real problem I ran into that took me weeks to figure out. I was working on a piece with a large background gradient and soft airbrush shading, and every time I zoomed in past 200 percent the edges of my soft brushes started showing banding and pixelation that wasn't there at normal zoom. I thought my display drivers were the issue. They weren't. The problem is that Sai's preview rendering at high zoom levels doesn't use the same anti-aliasing math it uses at normal zoom. The workaround is ugly but effective. You go into Settings, find the display options, and switch the zoom rendering quality to high if your version has that option. On older builds, the trick is to set your canvas resolution lower while you work, then duplicate the layer and use Image > Resize to upscale to final print dimensions only when you're done. The upscaling in Sai is decent for this purpose. It doesn't introduce the artifacts that upscaling in cheap photo editors does. Another thing nobody really talks about is how Sai handles color sampling. When you hold the eyedropper and sample from a complex shaded area, it samples the exact pixel underneath your cursor. In Photoshop, the eyedropper has a sampling radius setting that averages surrounding pixels, which gives you a more useful mid-tone. Sai doesn't have that. If you are trying to pick a color from a heavily textured area, you will get a stray pixel color that throws off your palette. My fix is to create a temporary solid-color layer below everything, flatten a small section of my painting onto it using a selection, then sample from that flat patch instead of the original messy layer. It takes five seconds once you know to do it. There are real limits to what this program can do and you need to know them before you commit. Sai has no CMYK mode. If you are doing print work, you export your files and convert to CMYK in another program, which means your final output colors will shift slightly from what you see on screen. Sai has no vector layers, so any shape work you do is raster-based from the start and will degrade if you scale it up later. There is no font text tool that supports advanced typography like OpenType features. There is no content-aware fill or advanced selection tool comparable to Photoshop's Select Subject. If you need to do photo manipulation or compositing, Sai will not handle it well. The program is an illustration tool, nothing more.
For people who mainly do anime-style illustration, lineart-heavy work, or clean coloring, those missing features rarely matter. For character designers who need to iterate quickly on shapes, the lack of vector tools is frustrating. For concept artists working from photographs, you are going to want something with more robust photo-sampling and adjustment capabilities. The installation is straightforward. You download the trial from the official website, run the installer, and everything goes into a single folder. The program is roughly ninety megabytes. It runs on integrated graphics without slowing down your system the way Photoshop does. I have run it on a laptop with eight gigabytes of RAM and it never hiccups on a twenty-layer file. The file saving format is proprietary, which means if you ever want to hand off a layered project to someone using a different program, they cannot open it. I deal with this by keeping a PSD backup of every project in Photoshop or Krita while I work in Sai. The export is lossless enough that the color values stay accurate when converted. If you are coming from Photoshop and trying to decide whether to switch part of your workflow over, start by using Sai only for lineart and flat coloring on one project. Don't try to redo your entire process at once. The brush feel is different enough that you will fight the software for a week if you force it. Give it three days of light use and see whether the stabilizer and the color behavior click for you. If they do, it will likely save you twenty to thirty minutes per illustration on the lineart and base color stage alone. If they don't, uninstall it and move on. The program is cheap enough that the risk is minimal.
Get the Full Details
